
“Your punchline can’t be, ‘F**k you.’” said the comedy show producer.
It wasn’t, Sir. It was, “F**k you, Mom!”
It was one of the first shows I ever did. The producer was a seasoned comic, in his late fifties or early sixties, hosting at Stand Up NY on the Upper West Side. He provided feedback to each comic who performed. He was dead wrong about this, though. The laughs I got from my joke tell me it was successful – that’s kinda the whole point of stand-up.
If you were to Google “F**k you” or type it into your text app, the algorithm is unlikely to auto-populate the word “mom” after that. No one sees that coming. It’s novel, guy. And it got the laughs.
I performed stand-up in New York City fifteen times between the summer of 2022-2023. It had been at the top of my bucket list for decades. After getting divorced, it was the first thing I pursued.
Performing in Manhattan is such an eye-opening experience. Did I make it as a comic? Absolutely not. You don’t earn a penny at open mics and you’re not invited by show runners, you just claw your way into a line-up. But I wouldn’t trade the memories from performing at a slew of clubs across the city for anything.
You might think that comedians are treated like royalty, since they’re bringing money into these clubs through tickets and drinks. The reality is, they’re not. They receive no special treatment whatsoever. The indignities these heroes who bring us the gift of laughter have to endure is, in itself, comedy gold.
For one thing, almost no club has room to house you before your set. Most up-and-coming comics walk in off the street just minutes before their set starts, and wait in a dark hallway or just outside the door to the stage.
The most luxurious waiting experience I had was being seated with ten other comedians in a basement storeroom, surrounded by stacked boxes of liquor, while a bartender blended margaritas mere feet away at the side of the room. We awkwardly tried making chit chat, keep our nerves steady before we went on stage. But every third word was cut off by the blender. We were offered free alcohol, and I accepted a gin and tonic. It was the only time I went onstage a bit drunk. I thought it would give me confidence. It was my worst set ever. I decided never to imbibe again before a show, because it commands all your senses.
There were times I had to crush myself against a wall in the entry to allow guests in. Waited on a staircase. Waited outside the club. There’s nowhere to put your personal items, which especially sucks in the winter when you have a coat and scarf. You just have to ball up your clothing and purse outside the door to the stage and hope no one steals your stuff.
The audience is always seated right at your toes. You’re staring them in the eyes, so you can’t blur out the crowd if that’s your public speaking tactic. Once there were chairs lining either side of the actual stage, which was distracting when guests arrived late and clunked up onto the wooden platform, squeezing me in.
I came into this game in my mid-forties. You always hear that to make it you had to have started in your teens. You have to grind through multiple shows a week, at least one a night.
Because I live in NJ, it required me to drive into the city and find parking, which is both expensive and nearly impossible. On top of that, in order for clubs to let you perform, you have to guarantee you’ll have 2-4 guests in the audience. I had to keep asking the same two New-York based friends to come to all my shows. When the requirement was four people, I struggled to find the extras. I called in favors from everyone I knew, even getting my sister to fly in from San Diego and my ex-husband to come. It wasn’t sustainable. I felt guilty for asking the same people to come out again and again. It cost them money in train fare, ticket purchase, and the two-drink minimum that every club enforces. If you don’t drink alcohol, the servers are happy to give you bottled water. But you’re still getting charged a minimum of $18 regardless of what you order during the show. I decided I had to stop pursuing this hobby.
Friends have asked me why I don’t just perform in Jersey. The short answer is that Manhattan is where all the real comedy action is, and if you can make there, you know your material will work anywhere. But if you can’t make it there, well, you should find another hobby.

You must be logged in to post a comment.